The following is taken from Mü ndene fra Estland (The Men from Estonia) by Erik Nø rgaard,(1) which is based on research in Scandinavia, Germany and the Baltic States including material never seen before from the archives of the intelligence services. What is so remarkable is how the Estonian CP, with only 140 members at the start of the process, could end up as the ruling party there. Presumably the story was similar in Latvia and Lithuania.
Estonia declared its independence on 24th February 1918 in the aftermath of the Russian revolution but it was immediately occupied by the Kaiser's troops until the German November revolution later that year. Soviet Russia tried to retake Estonia but signed a peace treaty recognising its independence in February 1920. The CPE had been illegal since its inception. In December 1924 400 CP members, as in Bulgaria probably inspired by Zinoviev to cover his earlier fiasco in Germany, attempted a coup. From the spring of 1934 until the first of January 1938 Estonia existed under a type of authoritarian Bonapartist regime. It was `preventive' in as much as it sought to block from power the native fascist movement (VAPS) which was modelled on the Italian one and supported by the Lappo movement in Finland. From 1938 the CPE members in prison - as well as the VAPS members - were released as part of a shift towards democracy. Estonian Communists in exile who had Estonian nationality and who had not taken part in the 1924 coup were allowed home. About one hundred communists were freed of whom about two thirds were still party members.
In 1923 the CPE had won 43,000 votes or 9.5% of the total vote in parliamentary elections. Obviously Communism then had a certain base in the country. The attempted coup in 1924 discredited and isolated them and its members were gaoled or fled to the Soviet Union where three prominent Estonians had leading positions in the Comintern: Hans Pö ö gelmann, Jaan Anvelt and Arthur Mehring with Johannes Meerits the next in line. In January 1930 the ECCI condemned the CPE for its right-wing deviations and lack of will to fight the social fascists and so on. The Estonian Party noted this and agreed to toe the line while Mehring was named as the first Secretary of the CPE CC. In January 1931 it was decided to dissolve the CPE illegal organisation in the interior, infected as it was with unsound views, and to rebuild it on a cell basis where the cells would have no connection with each other but would be linked by specially appointed comrades under the control of the Political Bureau and this whole new illegal apparatus should be led by a centre placed in a Scandinavian country but which could act independently and be responsible to the CC and the ECCI Baltic Section in Moscow. The party papers were to be produced in Scandinavia and smuggled into Estonia and this whole system was started up in the summer of 1932 in Stockholm. Johannes Meerits was the deputy first secretary and de facto CPE leader as the Moscow Party members were too fully involved with Comintern activity. In 1933 the whole CPE illegal apparatus was shifted to Copenhagen which by then also housed the CI West Bureau which had moved from Berlin. Meerits summoned his protegé , Karl Sä re, from Moscow to Copenhagen where there were two dozen Estonian CPers.
The CPE Conference held in Moscow from the 13-17 August 1934 adopted the new line of approaching the Left Socialists led by Nigol Andresen, a legal party with significant influence on the more radical sections of the working class, thus dropping the line of `social fascism' in order to combat the `fascist' government of President Konstantin Pä ts, the Peasant Party leader. During July 1935 Meerits met Andresen in Finland and an agreement was signed. In August 1935 the Seventh Congress of the CI took place where Meerits, Karl Sä re, Jaan Anvelt, Arthur Mehring and Albert Sakkart represented the CPE. On the 6th October 1935 the CPE CC met in Moscow and the new line was discussed. According to Erik Nö rgaard, Arthur Mehring informed Meerits that Johannes Eltermann, an old and trusted comrade and underground worker had been arrested in Estonia and upon his release had made grave charges of betrayal against certain CPE members and he had also criticised the Copenhagen centre for sloppiness and named Meerits. While the CPE members in Leningrad tended to back Eltermann, Arthur Mehring sided with Meerits and began a campaign to paint Eltermann as a police agent. It ended with the latter being murdered in February 1936 on the outskirts of Copenhagen by Meerits, Sä re and August Wakepea, an Estonian seaman.(2)Later that year, or early in 1937, Sä re went to the USA to work in the Estonian community there and Wakepea went to fight in Spain. After the amnesty and upon his return from the USA, Sä re would go back to Estonia.
In the late summer of 1937 Meerits heard of the arrests and liquidation of leading Estonian Communists in the Soviet Union. He is said by witnesses to have been panic-stricken by these events especially when it concerned his protector Arthur Mehring who had ordered the murder of Eltermann. Jaan Anvelt, Pö ö gelmann, Otto Rä stas, Rudolf Vakmann, Johannes Kä spert and many others were executed. Even if the CPE was not dissolved Nö rgaard believes that the physical liquidation of its leadership in the Soviet Union meant that it might as well have been. In the spring of 1938 Meerits was ordered to appear before the CI Control Commission in Moscow to clarify certain questions. He ignored the invitation. During 1938 the activity of the Estonian CP centre in Stockholm ebbed away. On the 16th February 1939 Meerits walked into the Stockholm police station and applied for legal status. He ended up as an agent of the Swedish political police, later the Finnish too and confessed to that. He denied working for the Gestapo but, says Nö rgaard, made them an offer which they refused thinking that he was penetrating their intelligence for the GPU. But by then he was demoralised and in a state of disintegration.
As part of his deal with Hitler, Stalin was granted not only eastern Poland but the `right' to annex, among other ex-bits of the Tsarist Empire, the Baltic States and Finland. The Soviet Union demanded and got from Estonia a treaty giving them the right to naval and air bases and to station troops there. Soon after the same thing occurred to Latvia and Lithuania. However Finland resisted similar demands and on the 30th November 1939 Soviet troops invaded that country and met fierce resistance, suffering enormous losses but, after 105 days of war, the Finns had to capitulate and lost 40,000 square kilometres of territory though they had preserved their independence.
After accepting the Soviet demands, Estonia had a new government but, in June 1940, a further ultimatum was presented demanding that a new government be formed which would be more susceptible to Soviet demands. The government resigned. More Soviet troops arrived. Andrei Zhdanov was sent to become the de facto governor of Estonia. He presented President Pä ts with a list of the ministers that he wanted in the government, all of them Left Socialists, left wingers or pro-Communists though there were no CP members, the latter's official membership being but 140 at the time. Johannes Vares Barbarus became Prime Minister, Nigol Andresen the Foreign Minister, Neeme Ruus the Minister for Social Affairs, Maksim Unt the Minister of the Interior and Alexander Jö eä ä r Minister of Agriculture.
Meanwhile Karl Sä re had succeeded in elbowing aside his rivals among the amnestied CP members and had become Zhdanov's right hand man taking part in planning the Communist takeover. According to Nø rgaard three Left Socialists, Andresen, Ruus and Jö eä ä r - who would soon join the CP - also took part. The filling of various posts was discussed and it was probably Sä re who suggested Meerits for the post of Prime Minister. Attempts were made to get Meerits to return to Estonia, where nobody knew of his now legal status in Sweden, but by means of various ploys he managed to avoid going back. By this time the Swedish police were censoring all communications from abroad and all those within the province of Norrbotten, a stronghold of the Swedish CP and the centre of the iron mining region. Meerits telegrammed Andresen to get Sä re to meet him at the home of Cay Sundströ m (3) in Helsinki. The Swedish political police then informed the Finnish political police of the meeting at Sundströ m's home though they failed to say that Meerits was travelling under the name of Nilsson and after getting a visa he arrived in Helsinki on 1st July 1940. Nø rgaard believes that the fact that the Swedes only told the Finns that `Nilsson' was a CI agent and the general paucity of detail, as evidence that Meerits was meeting Sä re on their behalf to find out what was happening in Estonia. Cay Sundströ m's house was illegally bugged by the Finnish political police and Nø rgaard presents the contents of the written police transcript which, until now, has never been revealed.
The man Nils Nilsson (i.e.Johannes Meerits) arrived at Sundströ m's home at 10.30 on 1 July 1940. His appearance is described. The conversation was in Swedish. It was rather general. Meerits did not tell the truth about his situation. Cay Sundströ m expressed surprise that the Soviet Union did not demand a new government in Finland as part of the peace treaty. He talked of the isolation of the left in the party. The workers did not support the Soviet Union. Mauri Ryö mä , another left MP, was in prison. Sundströ m asked Meerits if he knew Hella Wuolijoki, the well-known author of Estonian origin. Meerits replied that he knew her via Moskvin, the CI secretary.(5) Sundströ m proposed that Meerits visit Wuolijoki. She had been used to put out peace feelers to the Soviet Union through Kollontai in Stockholm. Sundströ m told him that he was shadowed by the police and that he thought that his phone was bugged. He arranged a code that Meerits should use to find out if Sä re had arrived.
The author of the transcript then went on to investigate those on board a flight from Estonia(6). There was only one passenger on the Estonian plane, one Jaan Reeberg (that is to say Karl Sä re with a false passport provided by the Estonian government) who went first to the Estonian legation and then carried on to visit Cay Sundströ m.
Their conversation was mainly in Russian with some German. Reeberg said that he was on a diplomatic mission to meet an `illegalist' who was coming from Stockholm, whose journey to Estonia he had to organise. He began to tell Sundströ m what was happening in Estonia.
"There had been great changes in Estonia. Officially there were no Communists in the government at present but it was completely under Communist control.The report on Reeberg's account continued
When Zhdanov had seen that Estonian bourgeois circles had not fully understood the significance of the Red Army's entry into the Baltic States and that the Estonian President had only tried to carry out insignificant changes in the government to satisfy the Russians, Zhdanov had ordered the Communists to organise workers' demonstrations with the aim of overthrowing the government. The latter had been totally successful. Large numbers of workers had taken part in the demonstrations under the leadership of the Communists and Left Socialists. The next time that Reeberg met Zhdanov the latter had said that it had gone far better than he expected. The traditions of 1905 and 1917 were still alive among Estonian workers.
"There had been talk that the Communists should join the government from the start but it was then recognised that this was far too early and would have made a bad impression abroad. The Estonian masses were not yet totally in favour of a Communist government. In any case Communist influence was guaranteed since all the present ministers had collaborated with the Comintern and the Communist Party. Since 1935 the Estonian Communists had had a united front with the Estonian Left Socialist Party and its leaders Vares-Barbarus, now the Prime Minister, Unt the Minister of the Interior, Ruus the Minister for Social Affairs, and Jö eä ä r Minister of Agriculture and various others.
"There were unpolitical people in the government but their roles were insignificant. The government is wholly under the control and leadership of the Communist party. Furthermore the Communist have taken control of all important functions in political affairs and other organisations"
"The Chief of the Political Police was an old Communist, Murro, who had been imprisoned fourteen years. The Workers' Militia is totally under Communist leadership. A special gendarmerie under Communist leadership had been established. The Deputy Police Chief posts are all occupied by Communists so that they can later take over as Chiefs. Inside the Ministry of War, after the Russian style, a special propaganda department had been established under the Communist Keerdo's leadership. In all, over 300 Communists have got leading posts inside the government machine and a continual large scale purge is under way. All supporters of the old regime must go!Nø rgaard points out that the head of the political police, Tuulse, ordered the destruction of the archives and then he and his wife killed themselves with poison.
Zhdanov had arranged for a Russian GPU man to take over the whole purging operation. He does not appear officially but has a special secret residence and carries out his directives through Estonian Communists. Orders to arrest all the members of the old political police had already been drafted and some were already in custody including Kirsimä gi and Edesalu and well as the heads of the sections in Narva and Pä rnu. The previous police Chief has not yet been arrested but every day he has to visit the Russian Legation and tell the GPU man about the activity of the police and about the people employed by the political police The political police destroyed almost all the archives but lists of names still exist as well as some documents and Reeberg claimed that Sooman, Kirsimä gi and Edesalu were now ready to admit everything and tell all."
The report continues
"Sooman has explained that as he had only been a civil servant carrying out his duty he had nothing to hide from the new rulers and was ready to collaborate. Of the course the GPU man does not believe everything that Sooman says but the GPU want to ensure that, through him, they get to know about everybody who has collaborated with the political police. The Russians are especially interested in knowing how the big imperialist powers collaborated with the Estonian police and military and how the espionage against Russia was organised. Once the Communists have enlarged their cadre the whole police force will be reorganised. Reeberg believed that Sooman and other leading people will be sent to Russia to prevent them fleeing abroad."
Reeberg gave away other secrets and the report says,
"The government paper Rahva Hä ä l which appears instead of Uus Eesti is edited by Communists including the editor in chief and most of his staff. Also the paper Postimees which previously belonged to Tö nisson(7) is in Communist hands. Great changes will take place in the army with the purging of the old officers and the education of a new officer cadre as well as the establishment of political departments in the army. Rotberg, the present Minister of War, and Jonson, the Army chief, are supposed to be apolitical and it is believed that they will do everything decided by the Soviet legation and the Communist leadership. The previous Rifle Corps(8) has been dissolved and the new government has set up the so-called workers' militia under Communist leadership. Its chief is the previous political prisoner, Hansson, who took part in the Spanish Civil War on the side of the Reds.After recording the whole of the conversation between Reeberg (or rather Sä re) and Cay Sundströ m, the political policeman followed Reeberg into the town where, by chance, he met Nils Nilsson (eg Meerits) in the street and they then went to a restaurant but he could not hear what they talked about. Nø rgaard reminds us that, as he later records in his book, some fourteen months later, Sä re would be interviewed by the Finnish police when he was in Gestapo hands and he told them of what he had talked about with Meerits. It concerned his candidacy in the coming elections and, after his certain success, a top post for him. He proposed that they visit the Estonian Embassy that very day and apply for a passport but Meerits made excuses to avoid doing so. Sä re said that he had offered Meerits the post of First Secretary of the Estonian CP, a post that he himself had turned down to give to his senior. Meerits proposed one of the released CPers, Alexander Resev. Sä re did not then confess to offering Meerits the post of Prime Minister. Nø rgaard says that Estonian CP sources admit this and, in a letter from Nigol Andresen to Karotamm, the then (1943) first secretary of the CP, it reveals that the offer had been made with Zhdanov's agreement. When interviewed by Copenhagen police in 1942 Sä re said that he and Meerits also discussed the murder of Eltermann. (Nø rgaard guesses that it was bothering them as to whether he had really been a traitor and whether they would be found out. Wakepea, the other participant, had not been heard of since he went to Spain and had presumably fallen in battle.)
"The Communist Party, together with the Russian legation is drafting the orientation for the new government. Foreign policy will be determined by Russian directives and gradually there will be changes in the personnel of legations and consulates abroad. There will be changes appropriate to the Communist Programme in agriculture, the social sector and similar areas as well. For the time being the economic system will stay the same and agriculture will not be collectivised. Zhdanov said it could be a long spell before the Baltic States are sovietised. Much depends on international developments. If there is a threat of war for the Soviet Union then the process will be speeded up. The Communist Party have been active though illegal. A notice had been sent out that the registration of new members could begin. Reeberg said that many ministers and public officials would become members of the Party."(9)
The meeting at Sundströ m's home on the 2nd July 1940 was also bugged. Sundströ m proposed that the Soviet Union put pressure on Finland to establish a leftist government and mentioned which forces would support it. He offered to channel post from the Comintern to the Scandinavian CPs and discussed the Aaland Islands which were claimed by the Soviet Union. After Sundströ m left the conversation was in Estonian which the policeman did not understand though it is related to Finnish. Upon leaving Sundströ m's place Sä re and Meerits were arrested. Presumably this was a way of stopping Meerits from going to Estonia and something of which he approved. Sä re, on a diplomatic passport, could return to Estonia. Upon returning to Stockholm Meerits went into hiding. Envoys were sent to Sweden to fetch him and threats made too but the Swedes and Finns said that they could not find him. Swedish intelligence had him hidden away. In Estonia and apparently in the Soviet Union he was still regarded as an asset. The day Karl Sä re was arrested at his secret address - he was supposed to organise a partisan movement behind German lines - Meerits had visited Helsinki. Nø rgaard wonders if he fingered Sä re to the Germans through the Finns though this sounds outrageous.
The Estonian elections took place on the 14-15 July 1940. Nø rgaard describes how the swindle was organised. On the 17th July it was announced the League of the Working People, a CP front, had won and workers' demonstrations were arranged in Tallin calling for Estonia to become part of the Soviet union (though this had not been mentioned by anyone during the election.) On the 21st July Parliament requested unity. On the 6th August it became the 16th Republic of the Soviet Union. The same thing occurred in Latvia and Lithuania which joined the Soviet Union on the fifth and third of August 1940 respectively. Like the elections, it was all done without regard for the constitution or the law. Nø rgaard the describes what occurred in Estonia which included mass deportations. Karl Sä re became first secretary of the Estonian CP on 28th August 1940 and, together with Johannes Lauristin, president of the Council of Peoples Commissars, signed the mass of new laws patterned on the Soviet ones. CP membership went from 1,344 in early September 1940 to 3,732 in June 1941.
On the 22nd June 1941, 29 German divisions attacked the Baltic States on their way to Leningrad. Tallin was taken on the 28th August. Karl Sä re was captured on the 3rd September. Communist and Jews were liquidated. Sä re was removed to Sachsenhausen concentration camp and to its `prison within the prison' where prominent prisoners were held such as Captain Best, the British spy captured at Venlo, and later the DKP leader Aksel Larsen who survived to describe it. Later in 1941 or early 1942, Sä re told the Gestapo about the murder near Copenhagen in a desperate attempt to survive by being transferred to Denmark and tried under Danish law where he hoped to be gaoled.
The trial took place in Copenhagen and Meerits was delivered up by the Swedes. Sä re gave evidence after being coached by the Gestapo. He had no defence. Throughout, the trial was dubious under Danish law. After agreeing Meerits met with the Gestapo and changed his statement to be more in line with Sä re's. Sä re was kept in Gestapo hands throughout and after the verdict was never seen again. Nø rgaard has found no trace of him after that. Meerits later changed his story a number of times and obviously implicated Danish CPers to please the Gestapo. When the political prisoners escaped from gaol - Richard Jensen among them - on 21st September 1944, Meerits stayed behind though why is unclear. Upon the liberation of Denmark Meerits made a new statement saying that no murder had occurred and his case was re-investigated but he was found guilty though his sentence was reduced to fourteen years. He appealed but decided to be exchanged for a Dane gaoled in the Soviet Union. He was handed over on the 14th March 1949 and executed on the 1st March 1952 for spying.