Ciaran McConville’s play asks the
simple(!) question “What is love?”, and is at its best when engaging
most directly with it. The character of Alex, insightful despite his
learning difficulties, allows McConville moments of unselfconscious
poeticism. Mary, who gets involved with Alex’s elder brother and carer
Tom, is as perceptive but more straightforward: at the end of their
first date, when Tom protests that perhaps they should take it slowly,
she retorts, “To hell with that, I wore special underwear.”
Unfortunately, the play focuses increasingly on Tom, with Alex and Mary
appearing in a single scene each after the interval while Tom
progresses to the inevitable climax: a long-overdue confrontation with
the loss of his mother two years before the action begins and twelve
before it ends a couple of hours later. And so we are presented with
Tom’s tightly-buttoned self-sacrifice, his sister Sally’s not
cold-hearted but too self-centred careerism, and family friends Gerry
and Janet who in various ways – over-focus on work, adultery, heavy
drinking – serve as emblems of the possible down side of togetherness.
McConville is weaker when dealing with matters outside characters’
hearts and minds: the business of Sally’s media career dovetailing
helpfully with Alex’s new-found enthusiasm as a video maker is a
conspicuously convenient plot device. (It does, though, furnish
between-scenes extracts from interviews about love supposedly conducted
by Alex, with folk other than the cast giving apparently unscripted
personal responses.) The more the second act drives towards its
conclusion, the less interesting it becomes either thematically or
dramatically.
Kerry Bradley’s design is striking: the back wall of Trafalgar 2’s
broad, shallow space is hung with a couple of hundred framed pictures,
each with a blank tag hanging from one corner. Gradually we realise
that they represent memories of loved ones, with the tags representing
differing definitions and values of love from one case to another. The
snow metaphor, a little overdone in the script, is taken further by
clothing the entire auditorium in white, which is visually arresting
but conceals the seat numbers. Karl Davies and Katherine Manners lead
the cast of seven in performance quality just as their characters Alex
and Mary do script-wise; they are joined by Linda Broughton as Mary’s
mother, who seems to bring more lived experience to the most minor role.
Written for the Financial
Times.