Much of high culture still behaves
sniffily towards “genre” work: horror, fantasy, science fiction. This
is our loss, since many significant issues are dealt with earlier and
better in genre work than in “legitimate” fields. For instance, the
themes of Matt Charman’s play here – the consequences of breaching the
principles of neutrality and non-interference when acting as an
observer in a foreign culture – have been regularly treated in various
Star Trek series ever since the
“Prime Directive” was first formulated over 40 years ago, and treated
with no less thoughtfulness and usually in around one-third of the
playing time. Should we pay more attention to Charman’s take on the
matter because it involves only a fictional west African country rather
than a fictional planet? Should we find it more credible that, instead
of having odd-sounding alien names, people and places here have no
names at all but are referred to merely as “the president”, “the head
of the military”, “the mountainous region”?
This is not to be dismissive of the play and production. Director
Richard Eyre helms a tight ship, with Anna Chancellor impressive as the
international election observer who Grows Too Involved and is then
horrified to find that others recognise as much; her early-second-act
impassioned outburst to a couple of villagers is crashingly unsubtle,
but the further out of her character’s control matters move, the better
Chancellor’s portrayal of someone who has lost touch with her task. As
the young interpreter who is similarly idealistic but has to live with
the effects of their conduct, Chuk Iwuji turns in a quality
performance. Cyril Nri relishes a clutch of cameos from a bar owner to
the aforementioned head of the military, and in a smart piece of
casting, that personification of personableness James Fleet is a
Foreign Office spook who combines Machiavellianism with banality in his
reports back to London.
The play is about the emergence versus the imposition of values,
Realpolitik versus principle, spin versus substance, and above all
about consequences and the difference it makes when one has to stick
around as they unfold. These are mature matters, but they are not fresh
ones, and I’m afraid I’m unconvinced that the dark skins and use of the
Igbo language here are a qualitatively different kind of exotica from
bumpy foreheads and speaking in Klingon. Qapla’.
Written for the Financial
Times.