Mark Antony refers to the dead Brutus at
the end of this play as "the noblest Roman of them all", but there is
precious little nobility in the world of Lucy Bailey's production, in
which the urban mob of the first half are if anything more violent than
the contending armies of the second. As the audience enter, two men
onstage are fighting animalistically to the death; the opening of the
play proper shows just as atavistic a version of the feast of Lupercal,
before we get into the business of Caesar and his assassins.
This is, in effect, the
Rome
of the BBC/HBO television series which so divided opinions in its
graphic depiction of what is claimed to be the unsalubrious historical
reality. Programme essays here argue that "noble Rome" is an invention
of the last century or two, yet Shakespeare's own work, not least his
early narrative poem
The Rape of
Lucrece, gives the lie to such a view. Bailey and designer
William Dudley overplay their hand with this grim vision, its video
backdrops of seething crowds and the Capitol in CGI flames.
Although he played Brutus in the RSC’s 2001 production, Caesar himself
is a very Greg Hicks role. Hicks is not afraid to inhabit the arrogance
of a character who habitually refers to himself in the third person and
whose ambition is conspicuous, whatever Mark Antony may say to the
contrary in his funeral oration. Darrell D'Silva's Antony is a bruiser
who suddenly shows his calculating side in that magnificently
structured demagogic funeral speech. As the chief conspirators, Sam
Troughton (following his father David into RSC leads) is a principled
but occasionally febrile Brutus who almost collapses under the
interrogation of his wife Portia, while John Mackay's Cassius is as
lean and hungry as required, but his principal function is to be less
noble than Brutus. There it is, that word again; we cannot escape it.
To be sure, Shakespeare had contemporary political matters in mind when
he wrote the play towards the end of Elizabeth I's reign; but just as
certainly, he enjoyed the monarch's favour and used much of his writing
to enshrine officially sanctioned values. Rome may have been far less
ordered than we usually imagine, but this is a production in which mere
anarchy is loosed upon the world.
Written for the Financial
Times.