Helena Kaut-Howson’s version of Chekhov
is bedevilled by contradictions. She claims a greater immediacy for it
since she directs as well as adapting and does the latter as a Russian
speaker rather than from someone else’s literal translation, yet she
acknowledges that her lead actor Jon Strickland improved her text for
“speakability”, which puts that extra layer of mediated interpretation
back again. She decries the “fossilising reverence” of the “venerated
English approach” to Chekhov, which normally results in under-paced,
elegiac productions, yet her own staging excels in languor. This is an
aspect of the central paradox of Chekhov production: the problem of
portraying social and personal inertia in a sufficiently dramatic way.
This is especially true of
Uncle Vanya,
which probably has the smallest amount of actual event of any of his
major plays: a kiss and a gunshot (which misses, of course), and that’s
about it to sustain us through, on this occasion, the better part of
three hours.
To give all due credit, Kaut-Howson has realised
her vision in detail. Sophie Jump’s design blends an all-purpose room
of mismatched wooden chairs, old dresser and the inevitable samovar
with a row of silver birches behind, so that a simple lighting and
sound change can take characters out of doors or simply into an
unspecified location. Strickland’s Vanya is a ridiculous man in the
Dostoevskian sense, his sorrows and frustrations banal, his eventual
Act Three explosion foredoomed to be inconsequential. Simon Gregor’s
Astrov could only be taken for either a beauhunk or a heroic thinker in
a milieu as starved of human interaction as this, since there is little
to distinguish him from Vanya save for hair colour and a few inches in
height. Hara Yannas makes herself so plain as young Sonya that one
cannot blame Astrov for overlooking her, and Marianne Oldham as her
stepmother Yelena is so much the urbanite at sea in the country that
she can scarcely summon up the energy to be adored by both Vanya and
Astrov. It all makes for a beautifully composed and delineated picture
but, alas, an almost entirely still one as well.
Written for the Financial
Times.