WHAT THE BUTLER SAW
Vaudeville Theatre, London WC2
Opened 16 May, 2012
***

What a lot of laughs there are in this Joe Orton revival! How few of them are by Joe Orton! Which is absolutely not to accuse Leicester’s greatest playwright son of being unfunny. In the few years leading up to this, his final play, he perfected the authorial voice of a depraved, polymorphously perverse 1960s Oscar Wilde. Here, when psychiatrist Dr Prentice accuses his wife of nymphomania, she haughtily replies, “My uterine contractions have been bogus for some time!” Later, Dr Rance, whose inspection of the Prentice clinic is interrupted by a chain of outrageous events in which he sees a best-seller, declares that his book will include “incest, buggery, outrageous women and strange love-cults catering for depraved appetites. All the fashionable bric-a-brac.”
    
His years of experience in the deliriously funny duo The Right Size have made Sean Foley probably Britain’s best director of farce business. However, sometimes the acting side slips away from him. The first rule of farce acting is “Play it serious.” Here, the high-calibre cast led by Tim McInnerny and Samantha Bond as the Prentices and Omid Djalili as Rance leave us in no doubt that their characters believe every twist and turn of the incestuous, cross-dressing, drink-and-drug-impregnated tangle is fiendishly important… but not that they do, not that they are those characters. They are so busy being overwrought that they smother the aphoristic filth of the script, the verbal smoothness that should counterbalance the increasingly chaotic behaviour. Djalili, in particular, spends much of the second half expertly eliciting laughs from tics of performance whilst failing to “sell” almost any of the numerous gags in his lines. (Imagine what the premiere performance of Rance must have been like, from Ralph Richardson.) McInnerny and Bond have the excuse that their characters are growing progressively drunker (there is some nice business with a series of concealed bottles of Scotch), which gives them freer rein as matters accelerate.
    
The finest performance is in the comparatively minor role of Sergeant Match, who spends all his time in a bewildered search for mostly non-existent people and for “the missing parts of [a statue of] Sir Winston Churchill”, which are indeed exactly the parts you’re trying not to imagine. The sergeant is played by that hugely talented physical-comedy actor Jason Thorpe, whose instincts and understanding of the form realise Foley’s ideas to an extent frustratingly lacking in his comrades’ performances.

Written for the Financial Times.

Copyright © Ian Shuttleworth; all rights reserved.

Return to index of reviews for the year 2012

Return to master reviews index

Return to main theatre page

Return to Shutters homepage